This store requires javascript to be enabled for some features to work correctly.

  • Voted best Jewelry Store in Chicago by the Reader

  • Voted coolest Jewelry Store in America by Instore Magazine

  • Custom & Designer Engagement Rings in Chicago

  • Our new storefront is now open at 1433 W. Chicago Avenue!

  • Free shipping when you spend over $100!

Real Love: Peyton & Eric

Real Love: Peyton & Eric

Two Proposals, One Beautiful Beginning.

When Peyton and Eric came to Adornment + Theory, they knew they wanted to do things a little differently. Rather than following tradition, they decided to design engagement rings for each other, working with our team to bring two very different inspirations to life: the nighttime sky and frogs.

After seeing the initial sketches, they kept the CAD renderings and finished rings a secret from each other until the big day.

For Peyton, there's so much to love about a ring that's “so unconventional and fits the celestial inspiration perfectly.” But their favorite part is how the two designs complement each other.

“The designs echo each other without being too ‘matchy.’”

Eric's frog-inspired engagement ring features a signet design, faceted green gemstone, and frog-leg details. It's a design that surprised even him.

“I still can’t believe A+T was able to design me a ‘frog-inspired engagement ring’ that so immediately captured both our hearts.”

The couple planned a trip to Costa Rica, where each would surprise the other with a proposal. Peyton arranged a romantic morning surprise with flower petals and breakfast in bed, while Eric planned a sunset dinner at a cliffside restaurant.

What we love most about Peyton and Eric's rings is how they celebrate individuality while still feeling connected. As Eric shared, the two are “constantly admiring how good they look together despite being so vastly different in concept and overall design.”

We're so grateful they trusted us to bring their ideas to life.

Every love story is different. Let's create something that feels like yours.

START YOUR BESPOKE JOURNEY